Today’s Solutions: September 27, 2021

Moniek Zegers says we shouldn’t be giving more but taking less.

Marco Visscher | December 2007 issue
Charity is in. Bill Clinton has written a bestseller about it and rock stars are organizing concerts. But Moniek Zegers, co-founder of the recently launched Dutch Comité tegen Goede Doelen Gekte (“Committee against good-cause lunacy”) says we shouldn’t be giving more but taking less.
What’s wrong with charity?
Moniek Zegers: “Western idealists often know far too little about the local culture of the region they want to help. They usually live with other expats and the local elite in an upscale part of the city, while the biggest problems are concentrated in remote villages. Moreover, good causes keep themselves afloat. If their governing strategies were effective, everyone involved would be out of a job. But this keeps fundamental problems from being solved.”
Fundamental problems?
“Charity is part of a sick system that is barely even up for discussion. Corporations exploit farmers and labourers in developing countries and political leaders pretend development aid ends up with the people who need it, while donor countries often actually profit from it.”
And charity organizations don’t do enough to about this?
“They create the impression that we can all save the poor from ruin if we fly in somewhere and build a school or drill a well. They rarely point out the inconvenient truths.”
Such as?

“That even fair-trade coffee is processed in the West while coffee-producing countries should not only supply the raw materials but the end product. Or take the fact that our fish consumption has prompted Western companies to move into African coastal areas, taking jobs away from local fishermen—who are going hungry.”
So what does work?

“A different global economy, changes to global politics. And if this sounds too abstract, let’s try to behave like responsible world citizens. You can affect the lives of poor people every day with your wallet or savings or pension fund —which is much more effective than being charitable.”

Solutions News Source Print this article
Todays Solutions

Decolonizing Science: Kiwi scientists...

At The Optimist Daily, we often feature stories about scientific discoveries that help improve our understanding of the biosphere. We ... Read More

10 Tips to prevent food waste in your...

Growing your own food is hard work—don’t let all that work go to waste. Here are 10 strategies to help ... Read More

6 In-season superfoods to add to your...

As we head into the fall season, many of us are looking forward to changing leaves and cooler weather, but ... Read More

This AI system is designed to protect...

The US is home to more than 40 species of bats, but habitat loss, climate change, and disease have taken ... Read More

Ancient footprints could be earliest ...

Exciting new research from a team of archeologists in New Mexico shows that humans likely reached the Americas far earlier ... Read More

How to avoid the three most common fa...

Fall is the season of beautiful leaves and cozy soups, but what might not be so pleasant is your fall ... Read More