BY THE OPTIMIST DAILY EDITORIAL TEAM
In a groundbreaking decision, a French civil court ruled that oil giant TotalEnergies misled consumers in a 2021 advertising campaign that promised it could reach carbon neutrality by 2050. The judgment marks the first time France’s greenwashing law has been applied to an energy company, setting a precedent for corporate climate accountability.
The court ordered TotalEnergies to remove misleading claims about carbon neutrality and energy transition from its website. It must also post a link to the court’s decision for 180 days or face daily penalties of up to 20,000 euros (about $23,300).
In addition, the company will pay 8,000 euros ($9,330) in damages to each of the three environmental organizations that brought the case: Friends of the Earth France, Greenpeace France, and Notre Affaire à Tous, along with 15,000 euros ($17,500) in legal fees.
TotalEnergies acknowledged the ruling and said it would “draw the conclusions of this judgment regarding the content of its website.” The court’s decision targeted general climate claims on its digital platforms rather than specific advertisements for gas or electricity in France.
Misleading references to the Paris Accords
The court found that TotalEnergies misrepresented its alignment with the Paris Climate Accords, citing evidence from the International Energy Agency (IEA), UN Environment Programme, and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). These institutions have consistently stressed the need for a rapid reduction in fossil fuel emissions to meet global climate goals.
By invoking the Paris Accords without clarifying that its strategy includes expanding oil and gas production, TotalEnergies created the false impression that purchasing its products supported a low-carbon economy, the court said.
Three statements were specifically ordered to be removed: the company’s ambition “to become a major actor in the energy transition” and “carbon neutral by 2050, together with society”; its claim to “place sustainability at the heart of its strategy in line with UN sustainable development objectives”; and its slogan to provide “more energy, less emissions.”
While the court declined to rule on the accuracy of claims related to natural gas and biofuels or the realism of TotalEnergies’ 2050 roadmap, the decision underscores the growing demand for honesty in corporate climate communications.
A new era for greenwashing enforcement
Environmental groups hailed the decision as a milestone. “This is the first time in the world that a major oil and gas firm was found liable for misleading the public by greening its image,” the NGOs said in a joint statement.
The ruling lands amid a broader European crackdown on greenwashing, as regulators work to curb deceptive environmental marketing across industries. The European Union has debated new penalties for false sustainability claims, though final rules remain under negotiation.
TotalEnergies, which rebranded from Total in 2021, pledged to invest more heavily in renewable energy while continuing to expand oil and gas operations. The company claims to have 30 gigawatts of renewable capacity, yet more than 97 percent of its 2024 income still came from non-sustainable activities, according to EU disclosures.
A separate criminal investigation by the Nanterre prosecutor’s office is ongoing.
Toward truth in climate communication
The case against TotalEnergies may become a blueprint for future climate litigation, both in Europe and globally. As consumers grow more discerning about sustainability claims, courts and regulators are increasingly stepping in to ensure that corporate promises match their practices.
For now, the French court’s decision sends a clear message: in the era of transparency and accountability, greenwashing no longer pays.
